It’s been 38 years since
Ronald Reagan in one of his first acts of president abolished the Mental Health
System Act that Congress passed and Jimmy Carter signed on his way out of
office.
Thirteen years earlier in 1967 during his first
term of governor Reagan accelerated the deinstitutionalization of the mentally
ill in state hospitals. To make it clear this isn’t a political issue per se,
as the process was started in the late 1950s by Democrats of whom many were
concerned about the rights of the mentally ill being compromised. The courts
concurred and the Republicans joined the dance for whatever reason whether it
was to reduce government costs or protect the rights of the homeless.
Fast forward to the present and listen to the
mental illness debate as it pertains to the homeless. Not a day goes by that
someone doesn’t blame Reagan for the homeless problem.
Think about it for a second. Either 38 or
51years have passed depending upon your measuring stick and people are still
blaming Reagan for the problem. Here’s a novel idea: Instead of spending so
much time blaming why don’t we try to come up with a workable solution? Since
Reagan we’ve had two Democrats and three Republicans in the White House and
control of Congress has flipped back and forth as well as being split. Yet the
best they can do is try to assign blame for the mental health morass instead of
working to address real issues that are manifesting themselves in school
shootings, chronic homelessness, and a host of other societal issues.
After a certain point basking in laying blame
for problems instead of stepping up and trying to solve them becomes the moral
equivalent of whining.
You see it everywhere. Young men who say
they can’t do something, blaming the fact they did not have a father to show
them. A murderer or rapist blaming what they did on abusive parents. Someone
blaming their lot in life on the fact no one gave them money to go to college.
Society encourages the whinny blame game. After
every mass shooting we become obsessed with not simply finding out why it
happened but what is to blame.
The Las Vegas shooter supposedly had money
problems. If that is what was to blame for a pure act of evil then two thirds
of the United States population should have been wiped out during the housing
collapse. The same is true of those striving to blame peer rejection for school
shootings. If that were the case life expectancy for the species would be
reduced to 12 years for males and 16 years for females.
We spend incredible amounts of energy
assigning blame whether it involves homeless issues and school shootings and
then using whatever we determine the “cause” was to get in the face of others.
We rarely have much energy left over to work on solutions let alone have enough
chips remaining that we can engage in the necessary give and take required to
get effective and lasting solutions in place.
Assigning blame has become the Great American
Cop Out.
Too often it is used to give oneself a feeling
of superiority, to ignore that pure evil exists in the world and must be dealt
with as such, or to simply satisfy a need to do something.
That is when blaming becomes
whining.
We know there are mentally ill among the
homeless.
By constantly blaming it on whatever you wish,
in this case Reagan, and not working toward a solution you become a whiner.
There has got to be better ways to run state
asylums or address mental issues without pumping people up with drugs. At the
same time the political issues — addressing the constitutionality of involuntary
temporary holds to the point there’s a better litmus test that can pass legal
challenges — need to be tackled.
We’ve also have to be willing to endure a rise
in our “un-comfort level” to find a workable solution that might include an
element or two we’re less than thrilled about.
It’s not going to be easy. It’s not going to
happen overnight. But given the fix we’re in today is essentially a modern-day
invention it is clear there is a way out of the cave we’ve gotten lost
in.
We need to keep searching for the way out
instead of sitting down and doing what Dr. Smith of Lost in Space fame did. Dr.
Smith was an expert at assigning blame, whining, and then wallowing in
self-pity before actively trying to undermine any effort to change the
situation.
Being addicted to blame is no better than being
addicted to meth.
We use it as a crutch to take the easy way out
and do nothing or to justify not healthily engaging the rest of society.
I’d like to think that Reagan’s actions on the
homeless and the consequential results imagined or otherwise is not the final
word on how America deals with mental illness.
This column is the opinion of Dennis Wyatt and
does not necessarily represent the opinion of The Journal or Morris Newspaper
Corp. of CA. He can be contacted at dwyatt@mantecabulletin.com or
209.249.3519.
Blame is the meth of politics