BY XIMENA LOEZA
CV Journalism Collaborative
Stanislaus County Sheriff Jeff Dirkse on Wednesday neither condemned nor condoned federal immigration agents who pepper-sprayed and detained a pregnant U.S. citizen in his jail’s parking lot.
Rather, he told a packed town hall that ICE’s conduct is not his responsibility.
Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, a 23-year-old Ceres resident who is 12 weeks pregnant, was pushed to the ground and detained Sunday by agents who were attempting to arrest a man who had just been released from the jail. She was released hours later without charges. The incident made national news and videos of her arrest have been shared widely.
Vargas Andrade was in the audience at the town hall, held at the Salvation Army Community Center in south Modesto and hosted by County Supervisor Channce Condit. Local immigration attorneys plus staff from Congressman Adam Gray’s office also spoke.
About 100 community members and a few other local leaders attended the standing-room only meeting, despite the heavy rain and winds that evening.
Learkanna Chong, a local activist, asked why Dirkse’s video statement framed activists as harassing ICE agents without criticizing the agents themselves.
“Can you, in front of all these witnesses, condemn the increased aggression of ICE in our community?” Chong asked. “They have been tearing apart families. They have been assaulting, and intimidating and harassing legal observers, immigrants, U.S. citizens.”
Dirkse said ICE is not his agency, and directed residents to Congress.
“I can’t speak to their actions. I can’t justify them. I can’t condemn them but I also can’t condone them,” said Dirkse, who cited a policy of not commenting on investigations outside his office.
In his video statement, posted Tuesday evening, Dirkse warned that harassing federal agents is a federal crime.
Mark Runnels, a local filmmaker who attended, said he was concerned with the tactics of federal immigration agents, and noticed racist undertones.
“Why is it that we’re only going after brown people?” Runnels said.
Sheriff says ‘nothing that I can do about’ ICE
In the video, Dirkse said deputies were not involved in any ICE enforcement.
“We are bound by state law, and state law prohibits us from participating in immigration enforcement. Period,” Dirkse said.
Asked at the town hall what he would do if ICE began going door to door in Stanislaus County, as residents said it has in Sacramento, Dirkse said he has no legal authority to stop it.
“The simple fact is there is nothing that I can do about it,” he said.
Dirkse also addressed a video from last week that has circulated showing deputies in a seemingly friendly conversation with ICE agents outside one of the sheriff’s facilities. He said SB 54 does not ban all contact with federal immigration agents. Instead, it limits that contact to specific circumstances, and he said the office follows those rules.
“Across law enforcement, we have cordial, professional interactions. That is different from assisting them in their enforcement activities,” Dirkse said in the video. “We are not federal agents. We have no immigration authority, and quite frankly, we don’t want any.”
At the meeting, he defended his deputies’ interactions with the agents.
“That is not a violation of law or policy,” he said. “We don’t provide food or water to them.”
Dirkse did bring up “a source of frustration” with ICE, lamenting that agents were not picking up more inmates from jail.
In 2025, during the first year of the Trump administration’s renewed mass deportation policies, ICE requested 324 detainers and the jail placed 224 on hold that met state criteria, but ICE only picked up 39 individuals.
An immigration detainer is a request from ICE asking a jail to notify the agency before releasing someone, or to hold that person so agents can pick them up. In the previous four years, ICE only picked up one inmate during the Biden Administration.
“They are not coming and getting them. And, again, these are all convicted felons,” Dirkse said. “They are stirring up drama that, quite frankly, none of us want when they can come and get another 185 convicted felons out of the community.”
Dirkse said the names, charges and release dates of everyone in his custody are posted on the Sheriff’s Office website. He said he assumes agents in the parking lot are looking for people who don’t meet SB 54’s criteria for transfer.
Responding to a resident during public comment who said she was nearly hit by an ICE vehicle on Ninth Street, Dirkse said deputies had pulled over an ICE agent driving on Highway 99 last week. The agent was not ticketed, although Dirkse said deputies reported him to an ICE supervisor instead.
The Modesto Focus attempted to ask Dirkse additional questions while at the town hall, but he refused to answer and referred reporters to his office’s public information officer.
Audience says ICE spreads fear, hurts business
Modesto immigration attorney Patrick Kolasinski, who is also representing Vargas Andrade, spoke to the crowd at the town hall. He alleged the newest-hired ICE agents do not have adequate training on things like how to safely stop a car, de-escalation and other basic procedures.
“If ICE is breaking the law, you have a right to arrest them,” Kolasinski told Dirkse. “I’m just telling you to treat ICE no better than you treat your constituents.”
Attendees spoke about how the recent ICE enforcement surge is affecting the community. Janeth Ramirez, 24, of Modesto, said her family’s food truck has lost customers, and that she and her mother are looking for second jobs. She was hoping to hear actionable solutions from her elected officials, but feels she was left with more questions than answers.
“It’s disappointing to hear that, but it’s expected,” Ramirez said of the meeting.
The Department of Homeland Security has identified the man arrested Sunday outside the jail as Fabian Santiago Martinez, a Mexican national it alleges was in the country illegally and charged with multiple DUIs. DHS said in a statement on X that Martinez accepted voluntary return and referenced a woman who they said interfered with the arrest, without naming Vargas Andrade specifically.
“Our ICE officer relied on his training to safely control the situation despite the combative, aggressive, and heinously vulgar conduct of the woman interfering with his lawful duties,” the statement said.
Vulgar comments toward law enforcement are generally protected under the First Amendment, and observers may record officers in public as long as they do not interfere.
Also on Wednesday, some Stanislaus County elected officials released a joint statement urging every city council, public agency and school district in the county to bar immigration agents from nonpublic areas of public property without a judicial warrant. They called on Dirkse to explain publicly how ICE gets access to people in the county jail.
“Over the past several weeks, ICE has significantly increased their presence in Stanislaus County,” Riverbank Mayor Rachel Hernandez said in the statement. “Just this weekend, our tight-knit community was shaken when a neighbor was detained in their own front yard.”