Despite controversy over the closed session interview process, longtime Turlock resident and current Ceres City Manager Toby Wells was appointed the next Turlock City Manager on Tuesday.
The Turlock City Council approved in a 4-1 vote (with Mayor Amy Bublak opposing) a three-year contract with Wells. The contract includes an annual base salary of $220,000.
The City of Turlock has been without a permanent City Manager since Robert Lawton left in August 2019. In October 2019, the City Council announced that they decided to appoint Turlock Municipal Services Director Michael Cooke as a long-term Interim City Manager through November 2020. However, in February the City Council started having closed session meetings with the City Manager position listed as the topic of discussion.
On Tuesday, the Council considered in open session a contract for approval naming Wells as the next City Manager. The hiring process was met with dissent from the Mayor and members of the public.
“It’s consistent that you’re not being transparent with the public. In a time when the community is saying to you folks, ‘hey, we don’t trust the way you’re driving this city — be more transparent,’ you hold a closed session interview — an interview that could have happened in public. We’ve had public attended events where we’ve interview people before. Nothing against Mr. Wells, I don’t know him…What is at issue is the fact that you basically hired this man in secret off a list from three years ago,” said Tim Redd, a detective with the Turlock Police Department.
City Attorney Doug White said that Wells was among candidates in the City Manager recruitment process that started in 2017 when Gary Hampton resigned. In 2017, the City contracted recruitment firm Robert Neher & Associates to find qualified candidates. Those candidates were then interviewed and ranked by members of three panels of community members and a panel of City executive staff.
Lawton was hired in 2018 from that recruitment process, but served only 13 months of his three-year contract.
“It’s nothing to do with Mr. Wells, but I stand here and I wonder…you spent $40,000 to find out if we should get a tax, you can spend $20,000 to run the panels like we always have here. It’s not right to choose a city manager based on the opinion of a few. We need help. We have big city problems here…I just don’t see how we’re going to move forward without the transparency,” said Westside Ministries director JoLynn DiGrazia, who was a member of the community panel during the last time candidates were interviewed for the city manager position.
“Having a closed session about this is absolutely heinous. This public deserves a hell of a lot better than what you’re giving them…Where is the transparency in this? Where is that? You people should be ashamed of yourselves for doing this,” said Cynthia McClellan.
“We’re sitting here discussing the most important decision we can make, and at the same time we’re talking about we want the public’s trust. Well guess what, when you do everything behind closed doors in 28 days…we did this, but we publicly told you we had Mr. Cook as permanent interim, that’s what we told you. So, here we are; we lied to you,” said Bublak.
Along with the closed session interviews in a shortened time period, the Mayor also voiced her opposition to the annual salary that will be paid to Wells.
Wells will be paid $5,000 more than Lawton’s base salary of $215,000.
City Council member Nicole Larson defended the Council’s decision to consider prior City Manager candidates in closed session interviews.
“Based on the situation this Council has been through in the last year and a half and the challenges we are seeing, and the election coming up in November…I’ve seen this city suffer from political influences involved with city administrators being hired and let go and because of that I wanted to ask the question if we could look at the people that we have interviewed before,” said Larson.
“The City Manager position is absolutely crucial for the tasks that we are charged with taking on in the city. Because of that and the issues that are coming up, this was a situational based recommendation and it’s something that I think we’re lucky to have it. I think we’re lucky to have a candidate who has been involved in our search process — the one our community members speak so highly of — and someone who is willing to step up to this challenge. I think there’s an assumption that if we do pay a head hunter ‘X’ amount of money…that they’re going to come and want to work here. I’m proud of this city. I’m proud of where we’ve been, but right now this isn’t the best we can be so I don’t know the candidates’ quality we would recruit right now and wasting the tax payers’ money on that when this isn’t the Turlock I want to sell to people right now,” continued Larson.
Vice Mayor Andrew Nosrati and Council member Gil Esquer also voiced support for the need of closed session interviews.
“People think we’re rushing this — I don’t know, maybe we are — but we’re out of time and if we don’t make a decision right now, if we decide to go forward with this (tax) measure it’s not going to happen. The people will vote for it or not, but if we can’t get it ready and on the ballot, it’s going to fail right off the bat. So, we need to do whatever we can to prepare. We need a professional city manager up here to do the job. And, as I noted earlier, no one had any objections to the person we’re selecting…We need to make some decisions. We need to get things done, folks,” said Esquer.
Wells has spent the past six years serving as the Ceres City Manager. Prior to that he was the Acting City Manager while working as the Public Works Director. This won’t be Wells’ first time serving the City of Turlock. He was an Associate Civil Engineer for the City from 1998 to 2000.
He has a Bachelor of Science degree in Civil Engineering from Fresno State and is a licensed Registered Civil Engineer.
Wells is slated to start his position on April 20.
“Mr. Wells understands Turlock’s needs because he has experienced them from multiple angles. Mr. Wells has lived in Turlock for 21 years with his wife raising his children in Turlock schools and was even a Turlock City employee at the beginning of his career. He was involved in the design of our regional sports complex, our Monte Vista Crossings that we all shop at every day and most of the downtown infrastructure as well. He then went on to work with private developers as a project manager. When he was working for the City of Livermore, he was recognized as the employee of the year. Later, when he arrived in Ceres…he was promoted to head of the public works and then appointed city manager. This is the first time…in 10 years that Turlock has potentially hired a person as our next city manager who actually has city management experience,” said Larson.
“Based on our current fiscal challenges, and lots still to come, I believe that Mr. Wells can hit the ground running. He will bring the much-needed consistency, experienced leadership and normalcy that we are trying to regain in the City of Turlock and at City Hall,” Larson continued.